01 March 2011

chevron and ecuador

[click image]


Don't ask me how the U.S. judicial system can rule on an 8.6 billion judgment in the Ecuadorean judicial system, but it seems they have. Judge Lewis Kaplan, whose record already sucks, says that attempts to collect this judgment "might disrupt the day-to-day business of a company vital to the global economy". That's the kind of stuff fascists say... but not the kind of stuff Americans say.
In the latest twist in a hard-fought international environmental case that reportedly could win a megabillions verdict for the plaintiffs, a federal judge in New York has granted a temporary restraining order banning enforcement of any judgment that might be awarded in the future by a court in Ecuador.

The request for a TRO by Chevron was part of a civil racketeering lawsuit it recently filed against the plaintiffs and a lawyer representing them, according to the San Francisco Chronicle.

Chevron had argued to the U.S. court that the plaintiffs, in a claimed memo that the oil company said was tied to another law firm representing them, had shown their intent to disrupt Chevron's business worldwide to try to collect any verdict, Reuters reports.

"Helter-skelter disruption for the sake of disruption ... is not in the public interest," said Judge Lewis Kaplan as he issued the order. "The worst that can happen is that the plaintiffs are delayed in enforcing that judgment for 28 days."

Kaplan ruled from the bench, notes the Associated Press.

The ruling yesterday follows a motion by a third law firm representing the plaintiffs, Emery Celli Brinckerhoff & Abady, to withdraw for unknown reasons, according to Corporate Counsel.

As detailed in an earlier ABAJournal post, one of the law firms representing the plaintiffs, Patton Boggs, is seeking permission of a federal court in Washington, D.C., to sue Chevron and Gibson Dunn & Crutcher for alleged tortious interference with its relationship with the plaintiffs.

A New York Law Journal article provides additional details about Kaplan's ruling.
I got on this to begin with at Public Intelligence, gaping at an ugly and inscrutable document they have posted for download, being reminded of Palast flummoxing Max Keiser the other day, and remembering about Greg being arrested in Azerbaijan, and wondering what he has brewing... and... well... so... ahem... just shoot me....

love, 99


  1. Hundreds of Wisconians realize you can instant message with your own mouth, free of charge."When the going gets weird, the weird turn pro." H.S.T

  2. Turn off the sound and watch the techie gadgetry erase ACTUAL brain function. That is a state senator that would have been beaten to a bloody pulp in 1776.

    Look at his death grip on his devise. Write now some pentagon programmer is writing a emergency exit finder app for their agent's iberry. Soon they will just have implants and the messages will scroll across their glass eye, "door 3, second from the end of the hallway, left". This is the Matrix. Put down the camera and participate already.

  3. Disgraceful.

    [A] large throng of protesters relentlessly heckles Republican State Senator Glenn Grothman, until he’s finally pulled away by Democratic State Rep. Bret Hulsey. As the crowd moved from fury and insults into a chant of “Peaceful! Peaceful! Peaceful!” Hulsey returned and addressed the crowd, asking them to keep it “peaceful and respectful.”

    That would have made me violent and disrespectful.


Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.